Useful Idiots, Seen From the CenterPolitical Opinion / Author's Analysis

Abstract

American political parties increasingly reward candidates who deliver reliable votes, partisan conflict, and turnout rather than independent judgment, competence, or truthfulness. This essay considers how primary-election incentives, coalition management, voter fear, and media dynamics sustain that outcome—and what centrist voters can demand in response.

In a two-party system, the most dangerous candidates are not always the most extreme. Often they are simply the most useful to party machines that value obedience, turnout, and outrage over judgment, competence, and truth.

American politics increasingly asks voters to make a choice that should embarrass both parties: back the most flawed candidate available, so long as he or she carries the correct label. The public language is tribal, but the logic underneath is transactional. If a candidate will deliver a reliable vote, attack the other side, and hold the seat, defects of character or competence become secondary.

From the center, that's the real scandal. The modern party doesn't need its best people. It needs its most useful people—someone who can win a low-turnout primary, energize a narrow but intense bloc, and then count on fear of the other side to bring reluctant voters home in November. The “useful idiot” here isn't just the loud extremist. It's any candidate whose flaws get excused because the label matters more than the person wearing it.

Both parties talk as if the political center is the prize they're fighting for. Their actual behavior says otherwise. Moderate and center-leaning voters are treated as default voters—people who may grumble but who show up anyway because the alternative feels worse. That frees party strategists to spend their real energy on the factions that dominate primaries: the angriest, most ideological, most online slice of the base. It is a rational strategy. It is also why so many of the most visible candidates in both parties are the least impressive.

The “big tent” is the mechanism that makes this work. It sounds inclusive, but it functions more like a holding pen. Parties invite fringe causes and single-issue activists inside, not because those factions will set the governing agenda, but to contain their energy and keep them from bolting to a third-party run. A slogan, a caucus seat, a hearing: give the base the feeling of being heard, while leadership, committee assignments, and the platform stay tightly controlled elsewhere.

The numbers explain why this bargain holds. Turnout in the 2022 primaries was 21.3% of eligible voters nationwide, only slightly above the 19.9% who turned out in 2018. In practical terms, roughly four in five eligible voters sat out the contests that decided who would even appear on the November ballot.[1] General elections draw a far broader, less ideological electorate, but by then the menu has already been set by the primary's narrower one.

Voters aren't blameless in this, but they are trapped by it. A Reuters/Ipsos poll released in June found that roughly two-thirds of party-affiliated Americans admit they sometimes vote for candidates they personally dislike just to stop the other party from winning, and 76% say they often feel they're choosing the lesser of two evils.[2] That's not simple partisanship. It's a permission structure for mediocrity: once a party's own flawed nominee becomes a shield against the other side, the question voters ask quietly shifts from “is this person fit?” to “will this person vote with us?”

Media incentives reinforce all of it. A legislator working through appropriations detail is rarely good television. A candidate who says something reckless or theatrical generates clips, ratings, and small-dollar fundraising, which teaches every future candidate exactly what gets rewarded.

There's no tidy fix here, and pretending otherwise would weaken the point. But voters don't have to pretend not to see the trap. A few practical questions before handing over support go a long way: Does this person respect facts when they're inconvenient? Can this candidate describe tradeoffs, not just enemies? Would this person still sound persuasive with the party label removed? The center can't rebuild the primary system by itself. It can, at minimum, stop rewarding parties and media for assuming it will show up no matter what they offer.

The views expressed are solely those of the author. This essay is a personal political assessment informed by publicly available sources. It does not represent the official position of any organization, institution, client, or affiliate. The author is a registered member of the Republican party.
© 2026 Michael E. Collins. All rights reserved.

Sources

[1] Bipartisan Policy Center, “2022 Primary Turnout: Trends and Lessons for Boosting Participation,” 2023. https://bipartisanpolicy.org/report/2022-primary-turnout/

[2] Reuters/Ipsos, “Party over purity: U.S. voters unlikely to turn backs on troubled candidates,” June 9, 2026. https://www.reuters.com/world/party-over-purity-us-voters-unlikely-turn-backs-troubled-candidates-reutersipsos-2026-06-09/

About Michael E. Collins

As managing member and founder of Expert of Counsel, PLLC (EOC), Mike provides expertise on geopolitical and national security issues, strategic guidance to corporate boards and senior management, and expert services related to business disputes and litigation support. Read Mike's Bio.