Nobody Is Vetting America’s Candidates Anymore
In 1968, Democratic Party bosses nominated Hubert Humphrey for president without his winning a single primary, even though Eugene McCarthy had shown real strength with voters. The backlash produced the McGovern Fraser Commission, whose 1970 report, Mandate for Reform, found that “meaningful participation of Democratic voters in the choice of their presidential nominee was often difficult or costly, sometimes completely illusory, and, in not a few instances, impossible” (Mandate for Reform). The commission’s guidelines pushed states toward binding primaries, and delegate selection stopped being a party insider’s job. It was the right instinct, but the fix removed the gate entirely rather than reforming it, and fifty years later we are living with what that tradeoff cost us.
States kept extending the logic. California and Washington adopted top two, all party primaries, and Louisiana runs what its own secretary of state calls a “majority vote in an open primary (jungle primary) system” (Louisiana Secretary of State). But a study of more than 18,000 state legislators from 1992 through 2008 found little or no consistent effect of primary openness on how extreme the winner turns out to be (Princeton). The problem was never simply who votes.
The 2026 midterms show the real damage. Crowded, low turnout primaries let an organized minority hand a party’s ballot line to a candidate carrying a modifier such as Democratic Socialist or MAGA, whether or not that label reflects the broader electorate. The Democratic Socialists of America backed 150 candidates this cycle and had more than 30 win or advance by late June, including a 29 year old first time candidate unseating a 15 term incumbent in Colorado (Washington Examiner; NPR). Building a real alternative is nearly impossible by design. An independent presidential candidate needs roughly one million signatures nationwide, a task Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s 2024 campaign estimated would cost between fifteen and thirty million dollars (NPR).
What passes for vetting today is mostly opposition research timed for maximum political damage, arriving after a nomination rather than before it. Graham Platner won Maine’s Democratic Senate primary on June 9, 2026, with 72 percent of the vote despite reporters having already surfaced a tattoo resembling a Nazi symbol and a history of deleted Reddit posts. A rape allegation surfaced a month later, his top endorsers pulled support within days, and he withdrew on July 11, forcing his party to pick a replacement for a seat that could decide control of the Senate (NPR; NBC News). Representative George Santos survived a House vote to expel him 179 to 213 in November 2023, with his own party’s majority voting mostly to keep him, two weeks before the Ethics Committee found substantial evidence he had broken federal law. He was only expelled in December, once public pressure made protecting his vote too costly (U.S. House Clerk; BBC). And in Ohio this August, Republican Senator Bernie Moreno publicly called for his own former son in law, Representative Max Miller, to resign over domestic abuse allegations brought by Moreno’s daughter, while the House Ethics Committee confirmed it was reviewing them. Miller has refused to step aside (Committee on Ethics; PBS NewsHour). None of these three were stopped before the fact.
Other democracies solve this differently, without giving up the vote. British parties run centralized, standardized assessment processes, such as the Conservative Party’s Parliamentary Assessment Board, before anyone can stand for office under the party’s name (Institute for Government). America has a domestic equivalent almost nobody discusses: fusion voting, written into New York’s own election law, which lets a minor party cross nominate a major party’s candidate and add its votes to the same total on a separate ballot line (New York State Senate). Congress runs a lighter version too. Senators Bernie Sanders and Angus King caucus with Democrats without ever adopting the Democratic label, gaining the party a working majority while keeping their own identity intact.
Four changes worth making follow from this record: a real certification process before anyone gets a party’s ballot line, wider use of fusion voting so a faction can build its own line instead of capturing someone else’s, formal caucus rules like the ones Sanders and King already use, and debate standards tied to professional judgment rather than donor counts alone. None of this undoes a primary vote or hands power back to party bosses. Democratizing who could vote was the right call. Removing every check on who could run was not, and Platner, Santos, and Miller are what happens when nobody performs that check until it is too late.
