What a Fairness Opinion Actually Says (and What It Doesn’t)Part 2 of a 3 part series on the Fairness Doctrine in corporate transactions

The other document from the Athlon file

Article 1 of this series told the valuation half of the Athlon Sports Communications, Inc. v. Duggan story: the multi-year statutory appraisal fight that ended up modernizing how Tennessee courts determine “fair value.” What that article set aside is the document that came before any of that litigation, the fairness opinion I delivered to Athlon’s board before the 2012 merger closed, working alongside the special committee and its outside counsel.

A valuation and a fairness opinion answer different questions, even when the same advisor produces both, as I did for Athlon. A valuation answers, “what is this worth?” A fairness opinion answers a narrower question: is the consideration being offered fair, from a financial point of view, to the shareholders receiving it? That second question is the subject of this article, and the distinction between it and “what is this worth” is more consequential than most directors, and more than a few advisors, appreciate.

The one definition the profession largely shares

The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA), the American Society of Appraisers (ASA), the CBV Institute (formerly the Canadian Institute of Chartered Business Valuators), the National Association of Certified Valuators and Analysts (NACVA), and the Institute of Business Appraisers (IBA) jointly adopted a single definition of a fairness opinion in the International Glossary of Business Valuation Terms: an opinion as to whether the consideration in a transaction is fair, from a financial point of view.1 That phrase, “from a financial point of view,” is not filler. It is the boundary of what the opinion covers.

The International Valuation Standards Council’s (IVSC) March 2012 exposure draft on fairness opinions is direct about what falls outside that boundary.2 A fairness opinion is not “an opinion or any form of assurance that the highest and best possible price is being obtained.” It is not “an assessment or evaluation of the sale or negotiation process.” And it is not “an affirmation of the strategic merit of the contemplated transaction.” What it is, instead, is a comparison: the value of what a shareholder gives up against the value of what a shareholder receives. A comparison between two things does not require either one to be independently published as a stand alone number, which is exactly why a fairness opinion can be delivered without ever stating a conclusion of value.

That gap between “fair” and “worth a specific number” produces most of the confusion directors have about what they are actually buying when they retain an advisor for a fairness opinion, and it is where I want to spend the rest of this article.

A current, verified example

Rather than describe a fairness opinion paragraph in the abstract, here is one, verbatim, from a transaction that closed earlier this year. When BioMarin Pharmaceutical Inc. agreed to acquire Amicus Therapeutics, Inc. for $14.50 per share in cash, Amicus’s board retained Centerview Partners LLC as its financial advisor. Centerview’s written opinion, dated December 19, 2025, as filed in the definitive merger proxy, concluded that “as of such date and based upon and subject to the assumptions made, procedures followed, matters considered, and qualifications and limitations upon the review undertaken by Centerview in preparing its opinion, the Merger Consideration proposed to be paid to the holders of shares of [Amicus] common stock… was fair, from a financial point of view, to such holders.” Goldman Sachs delivered a separate, similarly worded opinion to the same board. The merger closed April 27, 2026.

Notice what that sentence does not say. It does not say Amicus was “worth” $14.50 a share, or any other number. It does not say the board obtained the best price reasonably available, or that it ran the best possible process. It says the consideration was fair, from a financial point of view, and nothing more. That is the same narrow, defined phrase the profession has used for decades.

Not my first fairness opinion, nor my last

Athlon was not the first fairness opinion I signed, and the gap between that first one and Athlon is itself instructive. Years earlier, as CEO of 2nd Generation Capital, LLC, I signed the fairness opinion attached as Annex E to the going-private merger proxy for National Health Realty, Inc., a Maryland real estate investment trust (REIT) being absorbed into National HealthCare Corporation, a Delaware corporation. Dated December 20, 2006, that opinion addressed whether the $9.00-per-share-plus-preferred-stock merger consideration being offered to National Health Realty’s public shareholders was fair to them from a financial point of view, working alongside the special committee and its outside counsel in much the same structure I would later use on Athlon.

I chose National Health Realty as the illustration here not only because I signed the opinion, but because the transaction sits close to home for a Tennessee reader and because it previewed the kinds of complexities the third article in this series takes up in detail. Although the parent operating company was a Delaware corporation and the REIT a Maryland corporation, both were headquartered in Murfreesboro, Tennessee, in the same office building at 100 Vine Street, sharing the same main telephone number and separated by only a suite number. The two companies were closely related in substance as well as address: they shared a common major shareholder and had overlapping officers, and virtually all of National Health Realty’s real-estate business was conducted with the healthcare operating company as its lessee. Those are exactly the facts, common ownership, shared management, and one dominant counterparty, that make special-committee independence, mandate, and process the whole ball game, and that Article 3 will address.

Read today, that 2006 letter is unmistakably a period document. File references, tables, and formatting all mark it as pre-Athlon, pre-modern-DCF-litigation vocabulary. What is striking, comparing that letter directly against Centerview’s 2025 opinion for Amicus, is not how dated the 2006 letter is, but how little the underlying language has moved. Both opinions frame their scope and limitations, disclose the fee and any prior relationships, state the methodologies considered, and land on the same operative sentence: fair, from a financial point of view. That is my own observation from comparing the two documents directly, not a finding drawn from any published study. A widely cited empirical review of ten years of fairness opinion data examined valuation ranges, methodology choices, and advisor practices, not the linguistic stability of the operative phrase itself, so I would not stretch it to prove more than that.3

Three words that are not interchangeable

Directors, and the reporters and plaintiffs’ lawyers who write about them afterward, tend to use “fairness,” “value,” and “consideration” as though they are one concept with three names. They are not.

Fairness opinion has the shared definition described above. Conclusion of value and calculated value are AICPA-specific terms, defined in Statement on Standards for Valuation Services No. 1 (VS Section 100) rather than in the International Glossary, and they mean an estimate of the value of an interest, expressed as a single amount or a range. I did not find adequacy of consideration formally defined as a term of art in the AICPA, ASA, NACVA, or Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) materials I reviewed for this article; it is used descriptively by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), in Item 1015 of Regulation M-A, which requires disclosure of any report “relating to the consideration or the fairness of the consideration” without requiring that report to state an amount at all.

Delaware case law treats the fairness/value distinction as a working reality, not an academic one, even though a fairness opinion commonly relies on many of the same valuation analyses that a stand-alone valuation would use. In In re Trulia, Inc. Stockholder Litigation, the Court of Chancery held that stockholders are entitled only to “a fair summary” of a banker’s work, a summary that “does not need to provide sufficient data to allow the stockholders to perform their own independent valuation.” In Crescent/Mach I Partners, L.P. v. Turner, the same court observed that “fairness opinions prepared by independent investment bankers are generally not essential, as a matter of law, to support an informed business judgment.” A fairness opinion is a practice choice, not a legal requirement. And in the Rural/Metro litigation, the Court of Chancery’s liability decision found that the board’s financial advisor had aided and abetted breaches of fiduciary duty in the sale process; its later damages decision then fixed the stockholders’ loss using the court’s own going-concern value, derived largely from a discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis that came in well above the fairness range the board’s own banker had blessed. The Delaware Supreme Court affirmed both decisions on appeal. Three Delaware Chancery Court decisions, three different transactions, one consistent lesson: a fairness conclusion and a value conclusion are different findings, reached for different purposes, and are not owed to shareholders on the same terms.

Who actually writes fairness opinions and valuation reports

Boards should go into the engagement knowing the landscape of who they might hire, because the market is served by several recognizable tiers, not one standard provider. The four tiers below produce fairness opinions, standalone valuation reports, or both, depending on the provider, the engagement, and, as noted immediately after the list, professional-standards limitations on what a CPA firm may sign in a given role.

  • Large investment banks and elite boutiques
  • Big Four and other national accounting and advisory firms
  • Independent valuation and advisory boutiques
  • Individual credentialed practitioners and small advisory firms

A note on CPA firms and professional-standards limits. Under the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) Statement on Standards for Valuation Services No. 1 (VS Section 100), a CPA acting as a valuation analyst is professionally limited to producing a valuation deliverable, a conclusion of value or a calculated value, and the standard does not authorize a CPA in that role to issue a stand-alone opinion of financial fairness. In practice, that means CPA firms in the second and fourth tiers typically contribute valuation reports delivered separately, or delivered in parallel alongside a fairness opinion issued by another qualified provider, rather than signing the fairness opinion themselves.

Which tier a board should engage depends on deal size, the sophistication of the counterparty, and the degree of litigation risk in the transaction. Selection criteria should consider professional credentials and experience, preferably in dealing with businesses in the same industry and similarly situated. The risk profile of deals, and of public versus private companies, can be vastly different. Closely held private companies can pose unique challenges. Family, founders, and key employee shareholders can have widely different viewpoints on what is best for them as well as the company’s other stakeholders. Emotions can run high, and suspicion or allegations of insider dealing and personal agendas can arise. In my professional experience, boards and individual directors in such companies would be well advised to engage competent corporate counsel and valuation experts to help guide them in fulfilling their fiduciary duties.

What Article 3 will cover

This article has been about the fairness opinion as a document: what “fair, from a financial point of view” actually commits an advisor to say, what it deliberately leaves unsaid, and why the vocabulary has held steady for two decades of my own practice. Article 3 turns to the practical mechanics on the valuation side of the same transactions: how courts and practitioners weigh traditional approaches, including the Delaware Block method, against modern income and market approaches in statutory appraisal proceedings, including in Tennessee after Athlon, which freed trial courts to consider any generally accepted valuation method rather than mandating one.

Acknowledgments: I am grateful to Joan MacLeod Heminway, J.D. (UT Winston College of Law), and Paul S. Davidson, J.D., LL.M. (Holland & Knight), for their review and feedback across this series. Any remaining errors are mine alone. In this article in particular, responsibility for the legal citations and doctrinal framing remain the author's.
Michael E. Collins, CPA, ABV, CFF, Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) Series 7, 63, 79, and 24 (all Retired), is the managing member of Expert of Counsel, PLLC in Franklin, Tennessee. He served as the valuation and fairness opinion advisor to Athlon Sports Communications, Inc.’s board prior to its 2012 merger, and earlier, as CEO of 2nd Generation Capital, LLC, signed the fairness opinion delivered to the special committee of National Health Realty, Inc. in its 2006 merger with National HealthCare Corporation. © 2026 Michael E. Collins. All rights reserved.

Footnotes

  1. International Glossary of Business Valuation Terms (June 8, 2001), jointly adopted by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, the American Society of Appraisers, the Canadian Institute of Chartered Business Valuators (now the CBV Institute), the National Association of Certified Valuators and Analysts, and the Institute of Business Appraisers. See NACVA glossary.
  2. International Valuation Standards Council, Procedural Guidelines for Fairness Opinions (Exposure Draft, March 2012, comment period closed May 31, 2012). See IVSC exposure draft. This remains an exposure draft, never finalized as an adopted IVSC standard; it is cited here for its articulation of the concept, not as binding authority.
  3. Duff & Phelps/Kroll, In Defense of Fairness Opinions: An Empirical Review of Ten Years of Data, reported on the Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance (Apr. 19, 2017).

Citations referenced

About Michael E. Collins

As managing member and founder of Expert of Counsel, PLLC (EOC), Mike provides expertise on geopolitical and national security issues, strategic guidance to corporate boards and senior management, and expert services related to business disputes and litigation support. Read Mike's Bio.